Skip to content
CVChecl logo
  • Products
    • Our Checks
      • National Police Checks
      • Employment Reference Checks
      • Employment and Qualification Checks
      • VEVO Visa and Work Entitlement
      • Credit, Financial and Business Checks
      • Traffic and Licence Checks
      • Predictive Psychometric Assessments
      • International Checks
    • ID Requirements
    • Verify a CVCheck Certificate
    • CVCheck Help
  • About Us
    • Who we are
      • Our History
      • Our Mission and Values
      • Our Board
    • Why CVCheck
    • Integration Partners
    • Investor Center
  • Blog
  • Contact Us
Menu
  • Products
    • Our Checks
      • National Police Checks
      • Employment Reference Checks
      • Employment and Qualification Checks
      • VEVO Visa and Work Entitlement
      • Credit, Financial and Business Checks
      • Traffic and Licence Checks
      • Predictive Psychometric Assessments
      • International Checks
    • ID Requirements
    • Verify a CVCheck Certificate
    • CVCheck Help
  • About Us
    • Who we are
      • Our History
      • Our Mission and Values
      • Our Board
    • Why CVCheck
    • Integration Partners
    • Investor Center
  • Blog
  • Contact Us
CVCheck Checkpoint logo
Search
Close
  • Categories
    • HR
    • Recruitment
    • Talent Acquisition
    • Jobseekers
    • CVCheck News
    • Product News
    • News Affairs
  • Product News
    • National Police Checks
    • Employment Reference Checks
    • Employment and Qualifications Checks
    • VEVO Visa and Work Entitlement Checks
    • Credit, Financial and Business Checks
    • Traffic and License Checks
    • Predictive Psychometric Assessments
    • Working with Children
  • Resources
    • Articles
    • Announcements
    • Case Studies
    • eBooks
    • Infographics
    • Testimonials
    • Videos
    • White Papers
Menu
  • Categories
    • HR
    • Recruitment
    • Talent Acquisition
    • Jobseekers
    • CVCheck News
    • Product News
    • News Affairs
  • Product News
    • National Police Checks
    • Employment Reference Checks
    • Employment and Qualifications Checks
    • VEVO Visa and Work Entitlement Checks
    • Credit, Financial and Business Checks
    • Traffic and License Checks
    • Predictive Psychometric Assessments
    • Working with Children
  • Resources
    • Articles
    • Announcements
    • Case Studies
    • eBooks
    • Infographics
    • Testimonials
    • Videos
    • White Papers

Law change adds certainty to criminal record checking

  • Craig Sharp By Craig Sharp
  • on December 10, 2019

Recent changes to Commonwealth anti-discrimination laws give employers greater certainty in acting on criminal records revealed during background screening. CVCheck’s General Counsel, Craig Sharp, explains.

Changes to the Australian Human Rights Commission Regulations 1989, which are already in effect, allow employers to exercise reasonable discretion against prospective employees if their criminal record is relevant to the position being sought. 

Previously, employers had to show that a criminal record was directly relevant to the “inherent requirements” of a position.

Why the change?

In his announcement, the Attorney-General for Australia, Christian Porter, has suggested the change is a direct response to a controversy caused by a recent case. In 2018, the Australian Human Rights Commission (AHRC) recommended an insurer to pay $2,500 to a complainant for failing to employ him because of his previous convictions related to child pornography. 

The Attorney-General has signaled that the change is about finding “a sensible balance that ensures employers can reject an applicant if they reasonably believe they are unsuitable for a position due to the particular nature of their conviction” and removing what he described as a “much higher bar” for employers.

The 2018 case “demonstrated that our laws in this area were not working and were at complete odds with common sense which is why this change has been made,” Mr Porter said.

“The amendment that we’ve introduced will provide the certainty and clarity that employers need, while also ensuring that applicants remain protected when their conviction clearly has no relevance to the job they are applying for.”

What’s really changed?

Although the AHRC plays an important role in calling out discrimination and leading the discussion on best practice in Australia, the body doesn’t have enforcement powers. Upon summarising its findings, the AHRC concludes its recommendations for each case in a report that is then sent to the Attorney-General. But the AHRC’s verdict doesn’t make discriminatory actions unlawful and doesn’t mean parties need to follow or implement its recommendations.

Following the 2018 case, the insurance company disagreed with the AHRC’s conclusions and declined to pay the prospective employee the suggested compensation.

Regardless of the AHRC’s powers, any independent complaint process is a serious matter and can be a significant distraction from running your business. A complaint to the AHRC not only attracts unwelcome publicity but also represents a real reputational risk for any business.

The change in the regulation, from a criminal conviction that is “directly relevant to the inherent requirements of the position” to one that is “relevant to the position”, is a change that should be welcomed, because it is simpler and easier to understand. 

In reality, though, the change is not a dramatic shift from the existing law.  For the vast majority of employment decisions, nothing has changed.

Linkedin
Twitter

About Craig Sharp

Craig is General Counsel at CV Check Ltd and based in Perth. He is a practicing solicitor with more than 25 years’ post-admission legal experience, including more than eight years in the background screening industry.
More posts by Craig Sharp
CVCheck logo icon

CVCheck is a leading provider of background screening services in Australia and New Zealand, conducting over 300,000 checks every year for businesses, government organisations, and individuals. To learn more about our team and business, sign up to our blog today.

About the Author

Craig Sharp

Craig is General Counsel at CV Check Ltd and based in Perth. He is a practicing solicitor with more than 25 years’ post-admission legal experience, including more than eight years in the background screening industry.

Recent Articles

certification for quality control, which ensures that the company product meets its standards. on the virtual screen, there is a concept.

Organisations may not have the visibility needed to comply with the Critical Infrastructure Protection Bill

blog headers

Managing the burden of government oversight with ease

Child Worker Checks To Lower Child Abuse

Children’s Worker’s Safety Checks: How they can help lower NZ’s alarming child abuse statistics

businessman hand stopping falling blocks on table

Mitigating the risk factors your organisation faces every day

Browse by

Category

  • HR
  • Recruitment
  • Talent Acquisition
  • Jobseekers
  • CVCheck News
  • Product News
  • News Affairs

Product

  • National Police Checks
  • Employment Reference Checks
  • Employment and Qualifications Checks
  • VEVO Visa and Work Entitlement Checks
  • Credit, Financial and Business Checks
  • Traffic and License Checks
  • Predictive Psychometric Assessments
  • Working with Children

Resource

  • Articles
  • Announcements
  • Case Studies
  • eBooks
  • Infographics
  • Testimonials
  • Videos
  • White Papers

You may also like

Loading...
ikea screening practices
Ikea France’s screening practices under the microscope
GoBlitz
GoBlitz: striving to be the most trusted place to find a contractor
businessman hand stopping falling blocks on table
Mitigating the risk factors your organisation faces every day
Inlogik
Inlogik leads by example, prioritises security and compliance
CVCheck Checkpoint logo
Powered by
CVCheck logo white

Browse checks

  • National Police Checks
  • Employment Reference Checks
  • Employment and Qualification Checks
  • VEVO Visa and Work Entitlement
  • Credit, Financial and Business Checks
  • Traffic and Licence Checks
  • Predictive Psychometric Assessments
  • International Checks

Quick links

  • About Us
  • Resources
  • CVCheck Help
  • Contact Us

Checkpoint Newsletter

Subscribe now

Connect with us

Facebook-f Linkedin-in Twitter Youtube Instagram
  • Copyright 2022 - CV Check Ltd
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms of Access

Get the latest news straight to your inbox

Checkpoint provides smart and creative insights in the form of useful tips, resources and relevant information. Each month we will send you the best updates so you stay informed.