Skip to content
CVChecl logo
  • Products
    • Our Checks
      • National Police Checks
      • Employment Reference Checks
      • Employment and Qualification Checks
      • VEVO Visa and Work Entitlement
      • Credit, Financial and Business Checks
      • Traffic and Licence Checks
      • Predictive Psychometric Assessments
      • International Checks
    • ID Requirements
    • Verify a CVCheck Certificate
    • CVCheck Help
  • About Us
    • Who we are
      • Our History
      • Our Mission and Values
      • Our Board
    • Why CVCheck
    • Integration Partners
    • Investor Center
  • Blog
  • Contact Us
Menu
  • Products
    • Our Checks
      • National Police Checks
      • Employment Reference Checks
      • Employment and Qualification Checks
      • VEVO Visa and Work Entitlement
      • Credit, Financial and Business Checks
      • Traffic and Licence Checks
      • Predictive Psychometric Assessments
      • International Checks
    • ID Requirements
    • Verify a CVCheck Certificate
    • CVCheck Help
  • About Us
    • Who we are
      • Our History
      • Our Mission and Values
      • Our Board
    • Why CVCheck
    • Integration Partners
    • Investor Center
  • Blog
  • Contact Us
CVCheck Checkpoint logo
Search
Close
  • Categories
    • HR
    • Recruitment
    • Talent Acquisition
    • Jobseekers
    • CVCheck News
    • Product News
    • News Affairs
  • Product News
    • National Police Checks
    • Employment Reference Checks
    • Employment and Qualifications Checks
    • VEVO Visa and Work Entitlement Checks
    • Credit, Financial and Business Checks
    • Traffic and License Checks
    • Predictive Psychometric Assessments
    • Working with Children
  • Resources
    • Articles
    • Announcements
    • Case Studies
    • eBooks
    • Infographics
    • Testimonials
    • Videos
    • White Papers
Menu
  • Categories
    • HR
    • Recruitment
    • Talent Acquisition
    • Jobseekers
    • CVCheck News
    • Product News
    • News Affairs
  • Product News
    • National Police Checks
    • Employment Reference Checks
    • Employment and Qualifications Checks
    • VEVO Visa and Work Entitlement Checks
    • Credit, Financial and Business Checks
    • Traffic and License Checks
    • Predictive Psychometric Assessments
    • Working with Children
  • Resources
    • Articles
    • Announcements
    • Case Studies
    • eBooks
    • Infographics
    • Testimonials
    • Videos
    • White Papers

The 5 most valuable lessons from the Theriault Case

  • Craig Sharp By Craig Sharp
  • on February 11, 2018
Valuable Lessons From The Theriault Case
Share on facebook
Share on twitter
Share on linkedin
Share on whatsapp
Share on email
Share on print

Last week, news reports emerged of the case against Veronica Theriault, who was recruited to a senior SA government role last May. Theriault has since been sacked from the position and now faces a string of charges, including CV fraud. In this article, we look briefly at the case alleged by the prosecution and identify the key lessons for employers.

Share on linkedin
Share on facebook
Share on twitter
Share on whatsapp
Share on email
Share on print

Hiring the wrong person can be disastrous for your brand and reputation and extremely costly to fix. The most recent South Australian case of a prominent hire gone wrong, may have a clean-up and legal costs that are likely to approach several hundred thousand dollars. Here, I explore the lessons learnt and what you can do to avoid being next.

What happened?
Last week, news reports emerged of the case against Veronica Theriault, who was recruited to a senior SA government role last May. Theriault has since been sacked from the position and now faces a string of charges, including CV fraud.

The allegations
The prosecution alleges that Theriault:

  • Falsely claimed to be an experienced ICT professional with over 20 years in senior leadership positions with some of the world’s largest technology companies
  • Faked a number of university degrees
  • Acted as her own referee under an alias
  • Successfully secured a three-year contract, worth $245,000 a year, as CIO with the SA Department of Premier and Cabinet (DPC).

Later, an Independent Commissioner Against Corruption (ICAC) investigation into the legitimacy of her application led to Theriault’s sacking and subsequently charges of fraud, but not before she granted Alan Corkill, believed to be Theriault’s brother, a contract as “service integration team leader”. Corkill has been charged with aiding and abetting Theriault’s fraud.

Additionally, ICAC has opened a separate maladministration inquiry into the recruitment processes used by the Department, and an internal DPC inquiry has so far resulted in the dismissal of one of the three-person appointment panels and the resignation of another.

The lessons
Lesson #1 – Prevention is Better Than Cure
Effective pre-employment screening would have cost a small fraction of the time and money spent on recruitment and would have prevented Theriault’s fraud and the damage it caused. Instead, the costs of Theriault’s hire are mounting up.

The expense of the two ICAC investigations, the departmental investigation, the dismissal of Theriault and Corkill, hiring their replacements, and the prosecutions of Theriault and Corkill are likely to have already exceeded $750,000 – the total cost of the Theriault’s three-year CIO contract ($245,000 a year).

For the Department, the real damage is political. If a similar fraud had occurred in a private enterprise, comparable costs of investigation, disruption and potential litigation, as well as significant reputational damage, would have been inevitable. Employers who are actively managing the risks in their business (and that should be all employers) are well advised to make the relatively cheap investment in pre-employment screening to avoid the expensive and embarrassing consequences of putting right a mistake.

Lesson #2 – Never judge a book by its cover
In the Theriault case, a panel of high ranking, experienced people were allegedly deceived by the candidate. However, they are not the first to fall foul to CV fraud. In an earlier, unrelated, case, senior executives in a top tier retail business made a similar mistake when appointing a senior manager to a high-profile role. The reality is that no matter how experienced you are, you can never be completely sure you’ll spot a phony during an interview.

Lesson #3 – Check the basics
Routine checks to verify the qualifications claimed on Theriault’s CV would have prevented the fraud in this case and saved the DPC a great deal of pain and embarrassment. The checks you can use to verify previous employment details and qualifications are simple, relatively quick and easily affordable.

To manage the risk of a bad employment decision, they should be routine for every employee you hire.

Lesson #4 – Verify your referee
There are various ways of obtaining a reference, from a quick online questionnaire through to a detailed phone call, or a combination. All are potentially valid – the style of reference should always be appropriate to the position you are filling.

However, as the Theriault case demonstrates, whatever style of reference you obtain, if you cannot be sure who the referee is, you are wasting valuable time and money. Simply relying on a phone number, or email address, supplied by the candidate is leaving you exposed to the risk of CV fraud.

Lesson #5 – Adopt a screening policy and process
A thorough employment screening process is an integral component of risk management and an effective way of minimising and guarding against a range of potential risks.

It allows your organisation to have confidence in the integrity, identity and credentials of your staff and ensures that people you trust in your organisation are worthy of that trust.

More Information
Employment screening is the most inexpensive and effective way for you to protect your business against hiring risks and ensure you’ve made a good investment when hiring staff.

If you are unsure whether your employment screening practices are sufficiently robust, or if you would like some help in developing a suitable procedure, you can contact CVCheck.

Alternatively, you can use Australian Standard AS 4811-2006 Employment Screening as a basis for developing your own industry or organisational specific screening policies and procedures. It applies equally to organisations in both the private and public sector.

Linkedin
Twitter

About Craig Sharp

Craig Sharp is General Counsel at CVCheck. He is an admitted solicitor with more than 25 years post-admission experience, including more than seven years of experience in the background screening industry. Craig is currently the Chair of the Australian Committee of the Professional Background Screening Association.
More posts by Craig Sharp
CVCheck logo icon

CVCheck is a leading provider of background screening services in Australia and New Zealand, conducting over 300,000 checks every year for businesses, government organisations, and individuals. To learn more about our team and business, sign up to our blog today.

About the Author

Craig Sharp

Craig Sharp is General Counsel at CVCheck. He is an admitted solicitor with more than 25 years post-admission experience, including more than seven years of experience in the background screening industry. Craig is currently the Chair of the Australian Committee of the Professional Background Screening Association.

Recent Articles

Covid vaccination in the workplace

COVID-19: Can workplaces mandate the vaccine?

Case Study Medibank

How Medibank manages risk in a seamless recruitment process

Cvcheck + Cited

CVCheck acquires Bright People Technologies as part of strategic evolution

Combat Ageism In The Workplace

How to recognise and combat ageism in the hiring process

Browse by

Category

  • HR
  • Recruitment
  • Talent Acquisition
  • Jobseekers
  • CVCheck News
  • Product News
  • News Affairs

Product

  • National Police Checks
  • Employment Reference Checks
  • Employment and Qualifications Checks
  • VEVO Visa and Work Entitlement Checks
  • Credit, Financial and Business Checks
  • Traffic and License Checks
  • Predictive Psychometric Assessments
  • Working with Children

Resource

  • Articles
  • Announcements
  • Case Studies
  • eBooks
  • Infographics
  • Testimonials
  • Videos
  • White Papers

You may also like

Employment-Scams-Infographics-CVCheck-Checkpoint-840
Employment scams are on the rise
Organisational-fraud-Infographics-CVCheck-Checkpoint-840-2
Organisational fraud in Australia
How To Combat Risks With Aml Checks
Why AML checks are essential: PwC’s Peter Forwood explains how to combat risk
Avoiding Organisational Cyber Fraud
6 steps to avoid organisational fraud
CVCheck Checkpoint logo
Powered by
CVCheck logo white

Browse checks

  • National Police Checks
  • Employment Reference Checks
  • Employment and Qualification Checks
  • VEVO Visa and Work Entitlement
  • Credit, Financial and Business Checks
  • Traffic and Licence Checks
  • Predictive Psychometric Assessments
  • International Checks

Quick links

  • About Us
  • Resources
  • CVCheck Help
  • Contact Us

Checkpoint Newsletter

Subscribe now

Connect with us

Facebook-f
Linkedin-in
Twitter
Youtube
Instagram
  • Copyright 2020 - CV Check Ltd
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms of Access

Get the latest news straight to your inbox

Checkpoint provides smart and creative insights in the form of useful tips, resources and relevant information. Each month we will send you the best updates so you stay informed.